3.5m households can’t afford credit and essentials

21st October 2026

New research from the Centre for Responsible Credit has found that around 3.5 million low- to middle-income households in Britain, 44% of those who use credit, cannot afford both their essential living costs and their credit repayments. For these households, the median budget shortfall is around £633 a month.

The report analyses Bank of England/NMG survey data collected between September 2023 and March 2026, which follows many of the same households over time. For most households the shortfall is persistent: 2.6 million are still in shortfall when surveyed again at least six months later. At least £1.97 billion was lent during this period of the cost-of-living crisis to low- to middle-income households already in persistent shortfall, the report finds.

This indicates potential widespread breaches of Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) affordability rules. This new or additional lending went to over one million (1.15 million) low- to middle-income households who were already persistently unable to meet their essential costs (8% of low- to middle-income households, or 1 in 12). Collectively, these households hold at least £4.34 billion in consumer credit debt.

The report finds that around 1.5 million households in persistent shortfall are cutting back on food, heating and other necessities to keep up their repayments. Between them they owe around £7 billion in consumer credit debt.

The data showed that most of the new lending was mainstream. It was made through fully regulated credit cards, overdrafts and personal loans. This is the risk the FCA itself identified when it introduced its affordability rules, warning that without a requirement to assess affordability, firms “may be motivated to offer unaffordable credit to applicants who they expect to be profitable even if they are at high risk of suffering financial distress”. Buy Now Pay Later, which was unregulated throughout the period studied, did not account for a significant share. However, its lending to households in persistent budget shortfalls increased after Government’s decision to regulate it, indicating they may have been ‘making the most’ of the period prior to regulation coming into force.

Four in five non-mortgagor households with credit and a persistent shortfall keep up their credit repayments. But among non-mortgagors, 14.5% of credit-holders report bill or utility arrears, against 8.3% of those without credit, and 21.2% of renters with credit report rent arrears, against 9.7% of renters without credit. After controlling for income and savings, households with credit have around 1.7 times the odds of falling behind on household bills and more than twice the odds of falling behind on rent. Credit scoring disciplines borrowers to make their credit payments on time. Landlords, energy and water companies, and councils are left to pick up the bill.

HM Treasury’s Financial Inclusion Strategy aims to ensure that people can access “safe, affordable and responsible credit”. However, the Strategy does not define these terms or measure how many people are using credit that is unaffordable or irresponsibly provided. The report concludes that the FCA’s affordability rules and the Consumer Duty are failing to prevent this lending.

Damon Gibbons, Chief Executive of the Centre for Responsible Credit, said “Government is right to want everyone to have access to safe, affordable and responsible credit. But they aren’t measuring how many are experiencing the precise opposite.

“The data shows that over a million households were lent more by mainstream lenders when they could not already cover their essentials. That indicates a problem of widespread unaffordable, unsafe and irresponsible lending, which regulation is failing to prevent. Families are paying the price for this by going without food and heat, or by falling behind on rent and bills.

“We are calling on the FCA to strengthen its affordability rules, so that lenders check applicants against clear benchmarks of essential costs and families no longer pay for credit by falling behind on their bills and housing costs.”